In late October 2026, VCAT handed down its decision about a proposed drive-through Hungry Jacks at 194 Glenroy Road, Glenroy VCAT declared that it agreed with Merri-bek’s decision to reject the proposal. Many locals were delighted – the Hungry Jacks planning application had received 188 objections, with many concerned about walking and cycling safety.

Some key problems with the proposal were as follows.
Firstly, 194 Glenroy Road is situated in the Glenroy Activity Centre, which is intended to grow, housing more shops, business, community facilities and homes. Activity centres are explicitly intended to “improve access by walking, cycling and public transport to services and facilities“. (Clause 11.03-1S of Merri-bek Planning Scheme). In contrast, the Hungry Jacks developer proposed a high-turnover, drive-through, fast-food restaurant in that location. A development that priortised people travelling in motor vehicles rather people walking or cycling was a bad fit for an activity centre.
Secondly, 194 Glenroy Road is on a Council road. The vast majority of drive-through fast food restaurants are on arterial roads (i.e. roads managed by the state). Arterial roads are intended as the principal routes for moving people by motor vehicle. In the Movement and Place Framework, arterial roads have a “significant movement function”. (Of course, some arterial roads go through activity centres, which can cause significant conflict with people walking and cycling.) However, the site in question is on a Council road, making it more difficult to justify a development that would generate a lot more traffic.
Thirdly, there is a shared walking and cycling path in front of the site. The path is part of a Strategic Cycling Corridor. Merri-bek Council has designated it as part of a high priority “Streets for People” Corridor route reflecting its important role as a walking and cycling route to Glenroy Station, the Glenroy Activity Centre and Glenroy College.
The Hungry Jacks proposal included two driveways (the entry and exit) on Glenroy Road. Drive-through fast food restaurants attract a lot of traffic movements – far more than say an apartment block. Therefore many motor vehicles would have crossed (and obstructed) the shared path. Obviously this is bad for people walking and cycling.
So what do the rules say?
There were major changes to the Transport section (Clause 18) of all Victorian Planning Schemes implemented in December 2021. These changes places a much greater emphasis on safety and sustainability of transport. In particular, they specified the requirement to “Design development to promote walking, cycling and the use of public transport, in that order, and minimise car dependency“. (Clause 18.01-3S Sustainable and safe transport, emphasis added). Walking and cycling infrastructure is to be protected. In particular Clause 18.01-1S states “Protect existing transport infrastructure from encroachment or detriment that would impact on the current or future function of the asset”.
These planning scheme changes also introduced the concept of the “State Transport System” (Clause 18.01-2S) which includes: the Principal Bicycle Network; the Principal Public Transport Network; and the Principal Road Network (defined as arterial roads and freeways). Since that section of Glenroy Road is a Council Road (not an arterial road), its function as part of a Principal Bicycle Network is of critical importance in the state transport hierarchy. This definition of a State Transport System challenges the argument you often hear that roads are intended primarily for motor vehicles. In fact, on some roads, cycling and public transport is the main function of the road.
Interestingly, these changes to clause 18 came out in the middle of the VCAT case for another controversial planning application in Merri-bek – the proposed Bunnings Warehouse and timber yard at 145 Glenlyon Road, Brunswick. In 2022, VCAT agreed that this Bunnings proposal should be rejected.
There were quite a few similarities between the Glenroy Hungry Jacks proposal and the Brunswick Bunnings Warehouse proposal. The Brunswick site proposed for a Bunnings is also in an activity centre, and Glenlyon Road, Brunswick has on-road cycling lanes (which are part of the Principal Bicycle Network) and is part of Merri-bek’s Principal Pedestrian Network. In the Bunnings case, local walking and cycling advocacy groups argued that significant amount of traffic movements generated by a Bunnings Warehouse would create obstructions and hazards. This included vehicles blocking the bike lane and footpath. Glenlyon Road, Brunswick gets very congested at times. More traffic from the Bunnings would not only have increased traffic congestion, but also meant that vehicles leaving the site had to wait for a break in traffic. So there would be significant obstructions for people walking and cycling.
In the case of the Glenroy Hungry Jacks, the volume of traffic generated was not quite as bad as for a Bunnings. But Glenroy Road also gets congested. Moreover, the shared path on Glenroy Road also forms part of a Strategic Cycling Corridor (SCC). These are a high priority subset of the Principal Bicycle Network. There is now a particular clause in the planning scheme that protects SCCs. This states “Protect Strategic Cycling Corridors from encroachment by development and incompatible interface treatments such as cross overs” (Clause 18.02-2S).
194 Glenroy Road already has two crossovers on Glenroy Road. It was once a petrol station, which was closed in about 2007 and later demolished. Since then, the site has been boarded up or used for storage for the level crossing removal project. In 2007, there was no shared path on Glenroy Road and the concept of “Strategic Cycling Corridor” had not yet been developed. So cyclists using the Glenroy Road shared path had no experience of these crossovers being used by motor vehicles.
Another issue in the Hungry Jacks case was that car parking and drive-through dominated the front of the site. In an activity centre, developments should be focused towards people on foot. Or as the VCAT ruling stated: “the proposal does not achieve an acceptable design response to the activation of the street and does not adequately prioritise the pedestrian experience along Glenroy Road.”
So what would be a more appropriate use for this site? It is zoned Commercial 2 Zone, which rules out residential development. The zone is designed for a range of business and commercial services, including retail. The site was formerly granted a planning permit for “Construction of a three-storey building over basement car park, use of the land for shops and a child care centre”. The plans included 2 levels of underground car parking with 88 spaces, but the entrance and exit was on the side street (Blenheim Street). This development did not proceed. Since then, car parking requirements in the planning scheme have been reduced. This site is designated “Category 2”, which in effect halves the amount of required car parking. Such a land use would attract some traffic, but nowhere near the amount generated by a drive-through fast food restaurant . The site has been vacant for a long time, and being in the activity centre, we hope that it will be developed for a retail or other commercial use – something that priorities people walking and cycling.
